Hall of Fame
Located at the corner of North Main & Buchanan Streets -- Mayville, WI -- 53050
Mayville Lime School Museum, Inc. -- http://www.mlsm.org/index.htm -- Galleries 2nd Floor
The Rock River Hall of Fame was established in 1980 to honor former players, coaches, commissioners, and umpires who have made the league the success it is today. With an initial class of 25 inductees, chosen by their peers, the Hall of Fame was established in 1980. The number of inductees (as of 2024) currently sits at 264, as each fall new inductees are chosen at the Old-Timer’s Annual Awards Banquet. Anyone seeking more information regarding the Hall of Fame and membership into the Rock River Old-Timers should contact Bob Schultz at 920-285-3736 or bobschulz@charter.net
| Year | Inductee | Team(s) |
| 2024 | Dusty Jacobson | Neosho |
| Jami Kaul | Hustisford | |
| Tom Nickel | Waupun | |
| Kevin Schultz | Juneau, Mayville, Neosho, Horicon, Rubicon | |
| 2023 | Steve Held | Hustisford |
| Ray Lauersdorf | Neosho, Johnson Creek | |
| John "Butch" Salmon | Rubicon | |
| Jason Strobel | Kewaskum | |
| 2022 | Dave Donath | Kewaskum |
| Matt O'Rourke | Neosho | |
| Craig Semler | Rubicon | |
| Tom Theusch | Slinger | |
| 2021 | Andy Kasten | Watertown |
| Kyle Krueger | Clyman | |
| Terry Koth | Kewaskum, Long Lake | |
| Brad Tagliapietra | Brownsville | |
| 2020 | No Inductees - COVID | |
| 2019 | Shawn Burg | Rubicon |
| Tim Ladron | Clyman | |
| Eric Roecker | Rubicon | |
| Jeff Roth | Ashippun | |
| 2018 | Doug Gonring | Kewaskum |
| Charlie Hurtgen | Clyman | |
| Glen Lauersdorf | Ashippun | |
| Shane O' Hagan | Rubicon | |
| 2017 | Ron Bartels | Watertown |
| Craig Bunkoske | Horicon | |
| Randy Lorrigan | Rubicon | |
| Dan Schauer | Clyman | |
| 2016 | Tony Cole | Brownsville |
| Teddy Miller | Kewaskum | |
| Travis Steger | Neosho | |
| Jim Wittrock | Hustisford, Mayville, Waupun, Clyman | |
| 2015 | Jason Feucht | Rubicon |
| Don "Guy" Gourloe | LeRoy, Mayville | |
| Joe Parish | Watertown | |
| Jason Wesemann | Clyman | |
| 2014 | Norb Dornfeldt | Mayville |
| Tim Mommaerts | Clyman | |
| Ron Rose | LeRoy, Mayville | |
| Josh Stoffel | Brownsville | |
| Steve Zgonc | Clyman | |
| 2013 | Mike Bird | Brownsville |
| Lon Kreitzman | Hustisford | |
| Curt Kuehl | Mayville, Horicon, Hustisford | |
| Pat Rowoldt | Clyman | |
| Bill Steinbach | Mayville | |
| 2012 | Nancy Basol | Clyman |
| Andy Block | Watertown | |
| Tom Cole | Brownsville | |
| Tyler Kuehl | Hustisford, Watertown | |
| Dean Schwartzmiller | Mayville | |
| 2011 | Rev. Jim Castillo | Hustisford |
| Corey Held | Mayville | |
| Kevin Kohlhoff | Watertown | |
| John Roth | Ashippun | |
| Steve Schiller | Hustisford | |
| 2010 | Ron Held | Slinger |
| Curt Jaeger | Ashippun | |
| Bob Nelson | Hustisford | |
| Rick Ninmann | Hustisford | |
| Scott Sabin | Slinger | |
| 2009 | Corey Block | Watertown |
| Dave Dukelow | Neosho | |
| Gregg Kuehl | Hustisford | |
| Jim Reynolds | Hustisford, Lebanon, Watertown | |
| Chuck Selchert | Juneau, Horicon, Umpire | |
| 2008 | Tim Fitzsimmons | Clyman |
| Matt Hoffman | Woodland | |
| Russ Mueller | Hustisford | |
| Dale Nehls | Hustisford | |
| Dick Thieme | Umpire | |
| 2007 | Marvin Kuenzi | Lebanon |
| Stu Schramm | Lebanon, Watertown, Juneau | |
| Keith Schwarze | Horicon | |
| Tom Selchert | Juneau, Lebanon, Clyman | |
| Gary Will | Hustisford | |
| 2006 | Jim Heimerl | Rubicon |
| Jerry Held | Neosho, Rubicon | |
| Lynn Held | Hustisford, Lebanon | |
| Dan McGurk | Slinger | |
| Tom Thomas | Brownsville | |
| 2005 | Roy Lindert | Ashippun |
| Ross Roeseler | Neosho, Hustisford | |
| Dave Thimm | Ashippun, Hartford, Neosho, Horicon | |
| Larry Von Rueden | Ixonia, Watertown, Clyman | |
| Sylvan Weber | Rubicon, Hustisford | |
| 2004 | Dale Rettschlag | Juneau, Horicon |
| Dan Sabatke | Juneau | |
| Steve Salter | Slinger, Mayville | |
| Mike Urban | Oakfield, LeRoy | |
| Ron VanderGrinten | Eden, Long Lake, Campbellsport | |
| Gary Witthuhn | Reeseville, Hustisord, Rubicon, Lebanon | |
| 2003 | Jerry Bunkoske | Horicon |
| Ron Cole | Theresa, Brownsville | |
| Rick Held | Slinger | |
| Jerry Mullin | Randolph, Fox Lake | |
| Allen Weiss | Juneau | |
| 2002 | Harvey Buchta | Jefferson, J.Creek, Mayville, Brownsville |
| Ron Collien | Oakfield | |
| Bill Kreuser | Slinger | |
| Del Maass | Clyman, Lebanon | |
| John Steuber | Clyman | |
| 2001 | Warren Jahns | Oakfield |
| Steve Lehman | Juneau, Clyman | |
| Dan Stipanovic | Mayville | |
| Jerry Tighe | Mayville, Brownsville, LeRoy | |
| Dave Zimmerman | Slinger, Pardeeville | |
| 2000 | John Fetherston | Johnson Creek |
| Kirk Kaul | Hustisford | |
| Neal Kohlhoff | Clyman | |
| Randy Kuehl | Hustisford, Johnson Creek | |
| Larry Tennies | Slinger |
| 1999 | Wes Braunschweig | Ashippun, Clyman, Neosho |
| Don Harmeling | Horicon, Lebanon | |
| Ken Heck | Rubicon | |
| Ron Margelofsky | Mayville | |
| 1998 | Rich Block | Watertown |
| Lyle Braunschweig | Lebanon, Clyman | |
| Jerome Hetzel | Rubicon, Neosho, Hustisford | |
| Wayne Jahns | Oakfield | |
| Bob Redman | Waupun, Oakfield | |
| 1997 | Don Baertschy | Umpire |
| Jim Braunschweig | Johnson Creek | |
| Herb Mallow | Ashippun | |
| Freeland Rusch | Brownsville | |
| Bob Schultz | Hustisford | |
| 1996 | Bill Bergin | Ashippun, Watertown, Lebanon |
| Marv Grahl | Eden, Long Lake, Brownsville | |
| Ron Maass | Lebanon | |
| Jim Pirkel | Watertown | |
| Earl Roberts | Randolph, Beaver Dam | |
| 1995 | Dave Finke | Mayville |
| Ken Held | Neosho, Slinger | |
| Larry Held | Hustisford, Slinger, Rubicon | |
| Carl Keel | Burnett, Horicon, Juneau | |
| Greg Thiesfeldt | Long Lake, Brownsville | |
| 1994 | Chuck Braunschweig | Johnson Creek |
| Dave "Stub" Gourlie | Rubicon | |
| Don Held | Lebanon | |
| Phil "Hammer" Nehls | Hustisford | |
| Mark Rohde | Horicon | |
| Wally Rohrschneider | Hustisford | |
| 1993 | Don "Beilly" Beilfuss | Lowell, Beaver Dam |
| Bob Eske | Lebanon | |
| Ben "Bud" Kollmansberger | Mayville | |
| Al "Mina" Micklas | Mayville | |
| Bob Wolf | Slinger | |
| 1992 | Al Alt | Hustisford |
| Tom Hartwig | Mayville | |
| Art Hauser | Rubicon | |
| Bob Kampstra | Randolph | |
| Bob Kay | Rubicon, Neosho, Hustisford | |
| Marv Klawitter | Burnett | |
| 1991 | Wally Baumann | Lebanon |
| Dave Hash | Waupun | |
| David "Hawk" Jaeger | Ashippun | |
| Edgar "Zark" Kahlow | Mayville | |
| Gary Schwefel | Lebanon | |
| 1990 | Emil Baerwald | Horicon, Mayville |
| Chuck Erdman Jr. | Rubicon, Slinger, Neosho | |
| Francis "Fritz" Goebel | Long Lake, Eden, Brownsville | |
| Don Gourlie Sr. | LeRoy | |
| Harvey Vocks | Juneau | |
| Dean Wilderman | Horicon, Mayville | |
| 1989 | Jim Bartelt | Mayville |
| Harvey "Stubby" Bischoff | Juneau | |
| Bill Jaeger | Ashippun | |
| Claude "Cord" McCormick | Randolph | |
| Ray Messer | Burnett | |
| Dennis Schramm | Watertown | |
| 1988 | John Gennerman | Rubicon |
| Bernard "Nunie" Hauser | Rubicon | |
| Norman "Shep" Kettner | Hustisford | |
| Fritz Lautenschlager | Theresa | |
| Lyman "Dutch" Linde | Beaver Dam | |
| Ambrose "Mac" McTrusty | Oakfield | |
| Clarence "Smokey" Paul | Randolph | |
| 1987 | Francis Bellon | Horicon |
| Al Buchta | Mayville | |
| Clarence Hembrook | Theresa | |
| Jerry Hofmaier | Rubicon, Hartford | |
| Francis "Corky" Neu | Hartford | |
| Gary Schlieve | Hartford | |
| 1986 | Les Beitz | n/a |
| Wally Goetsch | n/a | |
| John Kling | n/a | |
| Wayne Neuberger | Clyman | |
| Verner "Prof" Spielman | n/a | |
| Eddie Wendorf | n/a | |
| 1985 | Glenn Dhein | Slinger |
| Bill Fetherston | Johnson Creek | |
| Harry Justman | Rubicon | |
| Norm Kutz | Long Lake | |
| Elmo Pomplun | Waupun | |
| Rudy Radloff | Hustisford | |
| 1984 | Will Braunschweig | Lebanon |
| Milton "Crash" Heimerl | Brownsville | |
| Harry Held | Neosho, Rubicon | |
| Harold "Shorty" Kuehl | Lowell | |
| Hilbert "Lindy" Lindermann | Ashippun | |
| Curt Schwantes | Juneau | |
| Romie Sterr | LeRoy | |
| Ed Stueber | Clyman | |
| Bob "Snapper" Vick | Woodland | |
| Gib Youngbeck | Mayville | |
| 1983 | Don Aschaker | Clyman |
| Max Bauer | LeRoy | |
| Ebie Braunschweig | Lebanon | |
| "Happy" Heimerl | Rubicon | |
| Ollie Krueger | Theresa (Posthumous) | |
| Irv LaBuwi | Hartford | |
| Steve Salter | Slinger, Mayville | |
| Walde Mueller | Hustisford | |
| Barney Roeseler | Hustisford | |
| "Mousey" Schraufnagel | Mayville | |
| Matt Serwe | Campbellsport | |
| "Gabby" Weyer | Mayville | |
| 1982 | Don Christopherson | Ashippun |
| Chuck Erdman Sr. | Neosho, Rubicon | |
| George Held | Hustisford, Neosho | |
| Ben Kollmansberger | Mayville | |
| Peter Martens | Juneau | |
| Tony Notheis | Beaver Dam | |
| Edgar Schiller | Hustisford, Juneau | |
| Jud Schlieve | Waupun | |
| Ron Stelter | Clyman | |
| Earl Sterr | LeRoy | |
| Andy Wondra | Campbellsport, Long Lake | |
| Gene Zangl | Mayville, Horicon | |
| 1981 | Darold "Jake" Collien | Oakfield |
| Paul "Eggie" Hauser | Rubicon | |
| Dave Kuehl | Hustisford | |
| Stan Nelson | Ashippun | |
| Rube Schuster | Theresa | |
| Lloyd Schwartzmiller | Mayville | |
| Bob Selchert | Juneau | |
| Hugh Roberts | Randolph | |
| Boyd Rohde | Horicon | |
| Ralph "Moose" Wolf | Slinger | |
| 1980 | Bernie Biel | Randolph |
| Norm "Lefty" Bischoff | Juneau | |
| Ozzie Bloohm | Brownsville | |
| Gibby Buchmann | Mayville | |
| Ray Dohrman | LeRoy | |
| Will Eske | Watertown | |
| Wilbert "Red" Hackbarth | Hustisford | |
| Carl Heimerl | Rubicon | |
| Ray Held | Slinger | |
| Fran Hofmaier | Slinger | |
| Cliff "Binger" King | Randolph | |
| Bob Kuehl | Hustisford | |
| Bronco "Brownie" Malesovich | Mayville | |
| Elmer Marks | Ashippun | |
| Howard "Sam" Narges | Long Lake | |
| Art Noll | Juneau | |
| Louie Plageman | Horicon | |
| Don Raue | Horicon | |
| Bob Schultz | Juneau | |
| John Sorgent | Mayville | |
| Paul "Zip" Stueber | Clyman | |
| Clyde Sturner | Lowell-Reeseville | |
| Merlin "Foz" Vergenz | Juneau | |
| Jiggs Wenzel | Rubicon (Posthumous) | |
| John Witt | Lowell-Reeseville |
